Defined Benefit
Insurance Assets
Nonprofit

The Gray Areas in Green Bonds

The Gray Areas in Green Bonds
clock
3 min 5 sec

Issuance of green bonds, which finance projects with a positive environmental impact, has exploded in recent years, and the space is expected to continue to show steady growth. Callan believes that active management is important for institutional investors that seek exposure to this segment of the market.

The first green bond was issued by the European Investment Bank in 2007 to finance renewable energy and energy efficiency projects (a focus on climate change is common for these types of bonds). Issuance is now commonly seen by sovereign entities, corporations, and from across municipal and securitized sectors.

The green bond market reached $1 trillion in outstanding debt at the end of 2020, according to the Climate Bonds Green Bond database. We expect issuance to continue to gain momentum given robust demand from investors that are keen to address climate change concerns by helping finance the global transition to cleaner energy.

Total Green Bond Issuance by Year (in millions)

A common challenge for those investing in green bonds is that there is no uniform set of requirements or standards. This makes analysis and monitoring more critical as a simple “green” label is no assurance that the use of proceeds, or the issuer itself, meets desired objectives.

The International Capital Markets Association’s Green Bond Principles is one framework, but compliance is voluntary. These principles were updated in 2018 and provide guidelines for disclosures from issuers. Separately, the Climate Bond Initiative (CBI) provides a green bond certification for issuers, and while it is considered to be the gold standard, there is a fee for this certification, and an “approved verifier” needs to ensure that the bond meets the required CBI standards. This is a difficult hurdle for some smaller issuers. Its standards are designed to ensure that issuance aligns with the Paris Climate Agreement to limit climate warming to less than 2 degrees Celsius.

Many are working hard to develop a widely accepted set of standards, but this important goal remains a work in progress. As a result, an important nuance has emerged: a differentiation between “labeled” and “unlabeled” green bonds. Labeled green bonds must meet certain certifications, as noted above. But active managers should have the resources and skills to ascertain whether a bond meets its environmental impact objectives regardless of the label it carries. These two examples provide some context on the challenge:

  • A labeled green bond that is “gray”: A Spanish oil and gas company issued a green bond in which proceeds were used to finance energy efficiency initiatives. However, some market participants may consider financing a bond that improves efficiency for a fossil fuel company as being incongruent with “green” goals and objectives.  
  • An unlabeled bond that is “green”: A privately owned mobile home park provides affordable housing for local workers and residents in a high-income area. It issued a bond, and a portion of the proceeds were earmarked for solar panels atop existing parking structures and buildings to lower electricity costs for residents. This issuance, which was not labeled “green,” provides positive societal and environmental impacts and thus fits well for a “green-minded” investor. 

Bottom line: Active fixed income management is key to identifying and analyzing green bond projects and issuers in the absence of global standards. Further, we believe it is important to evaluate the ESG characteristics of the issuer. If an issuer does not meet minimum ESG standards, then the use of proceeds may or may not make the investment appropriate for ESG-minded investors. Also, active management allows for relative value considerations to be incorporated into security selection decisions. In some cases, green bonds may command a premium due solely to the label. Finally, there is no assurance that a green bond issuer will use the proceeds as promised, so ongoing monitoring is essential.

Posted by

Share
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Related Posts
ESG

Interest in ESG Stays Level, Exclusive Callan Survey Finds

Hannah Vieira
Callan experts explain the results of the 2024 ESG Survey.
Public Markets

Stellar Markets Across Asset Classes

Kyle Fekete
Callan expert assesses the global markets in 3Q24 and the outlook heading into the election.
Public Markets

Gains for Stocks Mask Wide Disparities; Little to No Change for Bonds

Kristin Bradbury
Callan expert analyzes the global stock and bond markets in 2Q24.
Operations

A Deeper Look at How We Did With Our Capital Markets Assumptions

Julia Moriarty
An analysis of how Callan's Capital Markets Assumptions performed over time by asset class.
Public Markets

Stocks Continue Rally; Bond Returns Fall Amid Rate Cut Uncertainty

Kristin Bradbury
Callan expert analyzes the performance of global markets in 1Q24 and the outlook for the year.
ESG

SEC Releases Final Climate Disclosure Rules

Kristin Bradbury
An explanation of the final SEC climate disclosure rules and what they mean for institutional investors.
Public Markets

Stocks Near a Record High, and Bonds Reverse Course

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury analyzes global stock and bond markets in 4Q23.
ESG

The Heat Is On! Carbon-Footprinting Basics for Institutional Investors

Amit Bansal
Amit Bansal explains what carbon-footprinting means for institutional investors.
ESG

Callan Study Examines ESG Practices by Investment Managers

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury summarizes our 2023 Asset Manager ESG Study.
Public Markets

Tough Quarter for Stocks, with Bonds Facing Third Straight Annual Fall

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury assesses the global markets in 3Q23.

Callan Family Office

You are now leaving Callan LLC’s website and going to Callan Family Office’s website. Callan Family Office is not affiliated with Callan LLC.  Callan LLC has licensed the Callan® trademark to Callan Family Office for use in providing investment advisory services to ultra-high net worth clients, family foundations, and endowments. Callan Family Office and Callan LLC are independent, unaffiliated investment advisory firms separately registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940.

Callan LLC is not responsible for the services and content on Callan Family Office’s website. Inclusion of this link does not constitute or imply an endorsement, sponsorship, or recommendation by Callan LLC of their website, or its contents, and Callan LLC is not responsible or liable for your use of it. When visiting their website, you are subject to Callan Family Office’s terms of use and privacy policies.