Best Practices

ESG Mythbusters: The DC Plan Summer Blockbuster?

ESG Mythbusters: The DC Plan Summer Blockbuster?
clock
2 min 36 sec

Growing interest in environmental, social, and governance (ESG) investing is apparent across the institutional investment industry. ESG has also captured the attention of policy makers; for instance, the White House, the Senate Committee on Banking and Finance, the Labor Department, and the SEC have all addressed ESG in the past year. And we can read about regulatory activities, product proliferation, data advances, reporting frameworks, and other ESG issues daily in the media.

Despite the increasing momentum globally, consensus on some of the basics of ESG (aka sustainable investing) eludes many.

Enter the “ESG Mythbusters!” OK, not as catchy as the Avengers, but hear me out as I discuss how certain myths affect defined contribution (DC) plans, which have been slower to adopt ESG than other institutional investors, like sovereign wealth funds, nonprofits, or defined benefit plans.

In a blog post a year ago, my colleague James Veneruso highlighted low ESG adoption rates in Callan’s DC Index™. He found that 16% of DC plans offer a dedicated ESG option, with a fairly low utilization of 1.2% when offered, roughly on par with global fixed income and emerging market equity.

esg-myths-1-768x341
Source: Callan

Similarly, a survey by the Defined Contribution Institutional Investment Association (DCIIA) in 2018 found that 13% of DC plans had a standalone ESG option.

However, ESG integration was much more prevalent: nearly one-third of plans in this survey indicated that at least some of their options integrate ESG into the investment process.

To what extent does your defined contribution (DC) investment menu integrate ESG?

So what is the difference between offering an ESG option and integrating ESG, and why is it important to DC plan governance? As DC plan administrators are looking at whether or not ESG is right for their plan, we see a clear need for education around this topic and others, such as financial materiality and ESG’s impact on returns, to establish a common ground for productive discussions about implementation.

I recently co-authored a paper with other DCIIA members (my fellow Mythbusters) to address this need. In “Sustainable Investing in Defined Contribution Plans: A Guide for Plan Sponsors,” we aim to provide plan sponsors with a base level of knowledge about ESG/sustainable investing and integration by clarifying terminology and focusing on areas that historically have been misperceived. We tackle four myths that obfuscate discussions around ESG adoption:

  • Myth #1: There is insufficient research to support sustainable investing
  • Myth #2: Plan participants are not interested in sustainable investing
  • Myth #3: Adding an ESG-themed fund or requiring ESG integration is incompatible with fiduciary responsibility
  • Myth #4: Adding an ESG-themed fund in a DC plan and ESG integration are the same thing

While it may be a stretch to compare the financial wonks of the retirement industry to superheroes (although I call dibs on “Raucous Researcher” if we’re claiming superhero names!), I think this type of myth-busting promotes a more level playing field for administrators. Knowledge is power, and understanding how ESG fits within an investment framework and can be another tool to engage workers in saving for retirement will lead to well-informed decision-making on behalf of plan participants.

Posted by

Share
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Related Posts
ESG

Interest in ESG Stays Level, Exclusive Callan Survey Finds

Hannah Vieira
Callan experts explain the results of the 2024 ESG Survey.
ESG

SEC Releases Final Climate Disclosure Rules

Kristin Bradbury
An explanation of the final SEC climate disclosure rules and what they mean for institutional investors.
ESG

The Heat Is On! Carbon-Footprinting Basics for Institutional Investors

Amit Bansal
Amit Bansal explains what carbon-footprinting means for institutional investors.
ESG

Callan Study Examines ESG Practices by Investment Managers

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury summarizes our 2023 Asset Manager ESG Study.
ESG

S&P Global Moves Away from Numeric ESG Credit Indicators

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury explains why S&P Global dropped its numeric credit indicators and what it means.
ESG

The ESG Rule Explained, Part 4: The DOL's Goals

ESG Consulting Group
Tom Shingler interviews a legal expert on the ESG rule issued by the Department of Labor.
ESG

The ESG Rule Explained, Part 3: Shareholder Rights

ESG Consulting Group
Tom Shingler interviews a legal expert on the ESG rule issued by the Department of Labor.
ESG

The ESG Rule Explained, Part 2: DC Plan Lineups

ESG Consulting Group
Tom Shingler interviews a legal expert on the ESG rule issued by the Department of Labor.
ESG

The ESG Rule Explained, Part 1: Fiduciary Principles

ESG Consulting Group
Tom Shingler interviews a legal expert on the ESG rule issued by the Department of Labor.
ESG

Biodiversity: A Relatively New Theme for ESG-focused Investors

Kristin Bradbury
Kristin Bradbury discusses the relatively new type of ESG thematic investing focused on biodiversity.

Callan Family Office

You are now leaving Callan LLC’s website and going to Callan Family Office’s website. Callan Family Office is not affiliated with Callan LLC.  Callan LLC has licensed the Callan® trademark to Callan Family Office for use in providing investment advisory services to ultra-high net worth clients, family foundations, and endowments. Callan Family Office and Callan LLC are independent, unaffiliated investment advisory firms separately registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940.

Callan LLC is not responsible for the services and content on Callan Family Office’s website. Inclusion of this link does not constitute or imply an endorsement, sponsorship, or recommendation by Callan LLC of their website, or its contents, and Callan LLC is not responsible or liable for your use of it. When visiting their website, you are subject to Callan Family Office’s terms of use and privacy policies.